Note: Australia is generally considered to be a continental landmass, rather than an island. If however one does count Australia among the islands it, not Greenland, would be the largest in the world (unless one also considered Antarctica an island).
... Mate(Electoral Votes)
Thomas Jefferson (W)
162
Democratic-Republican
George Clinton (162)
Charles C. Pinckney[?]
14
Federalist
Rufus King (14)
Other ...