Encyclopedia > Voting system

  Article Content

Voting system

Voting systems are methods (algorithms) for choosing between different options. They are most commonly used in elections, but are also used for many other purposes: to award prizes, to select between different plans of action, or even by computer programs to evaluate which solution is best for a complex problem.

Table of contents

Criteria in evaluating voting systems

Various criteria are used in evaluating voting systems. However, it is impossible for one voting system pass all criteria in common use. For example, Arrow's impossibility theorem demonstrates that the following criteria are mutually contradictory:

  • The voting system should always give a result
  • If a voter improves the ranking of a particular option, that option should not be disadvantaged (monotonicity criterion)
  • Removing a candidate should not change the winner of an election unless that candidate is the winner (independence of irrelevant alternatives)
  • Every possible outcome should be achievable
  • Non-dictatorship (i.e. more than one person's vote matters)

Other criteria which have been used to judge voting systems include:

  • Proportionality
  • Simplicity - speed
  • Level of strategy
  • Reduction of potential for dispute after the fact

Another dilemma in voting systems is whether the system should choose a candidate is intensely popular among most people and intensely unpopular among the rest over a candidate universally but unenthusiastically accepted. This is the tolerances versus preferences problem, and it occurs in economics as well, e.g. in study of monopoly.

List of Systems

Single Winner Systems

Multiple Winner Systems (not party-list)

Allocation methods for Party-list proportional representation

Disapproval

In all of these systems, there is a choice about whether to include an option to vote against filling the seat. This is sometimes implemented by erecting a threshold which winning candidates must pass, other times by entering a theoretical "None of the above" candidate into the running.

The public dis/approval of specific ballot measures is called a referendum. Disapproval of a specific candidate in office is representative recall. It is noteworthy that both are means of publicly limiting and directing the powers of public officials or parties, but this aspect of disapproval voting isn't well studied. In the study of consensus decision making, the "blocking" of measures or nominations is a significant concern, and this literature may be of interest to anyone seriously studying disapproval of one or all of the choices.

Famous Theoreticians of Voting Systems

See also: political scientists

External Links

See also



All Wikipedia text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License

 
  Search Encyclopedia

Search over one million articles, find something about almost anything!
 
 
  
  Featured Article
Tsar

... of Troubles" Aleksey I (1645-1676) Feodor III (1676-1682) Ivan V (1682-1696) (joint ruler with Peter I) Peter I (Peter the Great) (1682-1725) (joint ruler with ...