Encyclopedia > Talk:Simply connected

  Article Content

Talk:Simply connected

The article said:
A subset X of Euclidean 2-space R2 is simply connected if and only if both X and R2 - X are connected.
I tried to correct this yesterday by changing "subset" to "bounded subset" and "connected" to "path-connected", but it's still wrong. It is possible to construct a bounded simply connected subset of the plane with disconnected complement. --Zundark, 2002 Feb 19

Thanks for finding the bug. I mindlessly copied it from Mathworld. Maybe we need X to be open? AxelBoldt

Never trust Mathworld. I think

A bounded open subset X of Euclidean 2-space R2 is simply connected if and only if both X and R2 - X are connected.

may be correct, but we need to check it before adding it to the article. --Zundark, 2002 Feb 19

a hollow ball is?

I smell inconsistency: a hollow ball (in 3D) can't be simply connected any more than a circle (in 2D). Whether or not they have a hole depends on your definition of hole.

Yes, it depends on your definition of a hole, which is why we give a formal of definition of simply connected which is unambiguous. A hollow ball (a sphere) is simply connected - it's intuitively obvious that a circle on a sphere can be contracted to a point. --Zundark 15:52 Nov 28, 2002 (UTC)

(I'm here to look up these concepts because the descriptions are infinitely better than those in the books of our math library's geometry/topology section, but there seems to be an imperfection here.)

The definition given is over my head: why involve the circle? If "simply connected" is meant to express the notion "completely filled up", isn't it better to define it as a connected subspace of which the complement's interior is also connected, or something like that?

Your definition does not give an intrinsic property of the space, it gives a property of the embedding of the space in some larger space. The idea of "simply connected" is that there is a path from every point to every other point (this is path-connectedness) and that there is essentially only one such path (thus "simply" connected), in the sense that any two paths from A to B can be deformed into one another. --Zundark 15:52 Nov 28, 2002 (UTC)



All Wikipedia text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License

 
  Search Encyclopedia

Search over one million articles, find something about almost anything!
 
 
  
  Featured Article
Northampton, Suffolk County, New York

... is spread out with 29.3% under the age of 18, 9.6% from 18 to 24, 30.3% from 25 to 44, 20.9% from 45 to 64, and 9.8% who are 65 years of age or older. The median age ...

 
 
 
This page was created in 77.6 ms