Encyclopedia > Talk:Arrow's paradox

  Article Content

Talk:Arrow's impossibility theorem

Redirected from Talk:Arrow's paradox

"their" vs. "his or her" has nothing to do with political correctness. It's the way the language is moving, at least in parts of the US. -- Zoe

That was a speculation as to why it hapened. Regardless, it can cause confusion on occasion - and here, where it's rather important to distinguish between individuals and collectivities, it makes a large difference. It would be all too easy to read "they" as referring to the collectivity. (I came across this important distinction in game theoretic stuff like the Tragedy of the Commons, where it actually drives what is going on.)) I think I missed some of the ambiguous usages, so I'll go back and tidy up further. PML.


Where there are only two choices, Arrow's theorem doesn't appear to hold. You can simply apply first past the post, which meets all the criteria mentioned when there are only two choices (meet universality by letting the first voter decide where there is a tie). Do we need to change "among several different options" to "among at least three options"? Martin

Read the theorem again (it's below the list of desired properties), and you'll see that it doesn't claim anything if there are fewer than three options. --Zundark 18:46 2 Jul 2003 (UTC)

Ahh, missed that bit, thanks. But "and the society has at least 2 members" - huh? If the society has only one member, Arrow's theorem holds by non-dictatorship and citizen sovereignty alone, surely? Martin 19:42 2 Jul 2003 (UTC)

You're right that the theorem is true without the at-least-2-members restriction. (But you do need monotonicity to prove this.) The no-dictatorship property can hardly be considered "desirable" in the 1-member case, though, which is probably why the restriction to two or more members was included. You can remove it if you think it's confusing. --Zundark 21:18 2 Jul 2003 (UTC)

Oh yes - of course you need monotonicity - otherwise the method could simply give the reverse of the society member. Neat. :)



All Wikipedia text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License

 
  Search Encyclopedia

Search over one million articles, find something about almost anything!
 
 
  
  Featured Article
Shinnecock Hills, New York

... $32,500 for females. The per capita income for the town is $28,378. 13.9% of the population and 7.7% of families are below the poverty line. Out of the total people ...

 
 
 
This page was created in 22.2 ms